Moodle

mp3s do not play in Moodle with latest versions of Flash installed

Details

  • Type: Sub-task Sub-task
  • Status: Closed Closed
  • Priority: Major Major
  • Resolution: Fixed
  • Affects Version/s: 1.6.5, 1.6.6, 1.7, 1.7.1, 1.7.2, 1.7.3, 1.7.4, 1.8, 1.8.1, 1.8.2, 1.8.3, 1.8.4, 1.8.5, 1.9
  • Fix Version/s: 2.0.3
  • Component/s: Filters
  • Labels:
  • Environment:
    IE, Firefox
  • Affected Branches:
    MOODLE_16_STABLE, MOODLE_17_STABLE, MOODLE_18_STABLE, MOODLE_19_STABLE
  • Fixed Branches:
    MOODLE_20_STABLE

Description

This issue is described here:
http://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=93755

Activity

Hide
N Hansen added a comment -

I'd just like to add that this problem is going to become more and more widespread as Flash players automatically update in more and more users' browsers and become incompatible with Moodle. I've had two students (and myself) with this problem in the last few days. Downgrading is only a temporary option. I've already come across other sites that don't work with the downgraded version and even if we downgrade, Adobe will automatically upgrade us again.

Show
N Hansen added a comment - I'd just like to add that this problem is going to become more and more widespread as Flash players automatically update in more and more users' browsers and become incompatible with Moodle. I've had two students (and myself) with this problem in the last few days. Downgrading is only a temporary option. I've already come across other sites that don't work with the downgraded version and even if we downgrade, Adobe will automatically upgrade us again.
Hide
Jim Eckhardt added a comment -

Downgrading is realy only a viable option (workaround) for the teacher.

In my case students are all over the US so its not resonable to ask them all to download /downgrade and not allow auto upgrade again.

I have a large number of small mp3s to teach another language. I may need to explore other options outside of the filter but if this worked it would sure be the easy way.

Show
Jim Eckhardt added a comment - Downgrading is realy only a viable option (workaround) for the teacher. In my case students are all over the US so its not resonable to ask them all to download /downgrade and not allow auto upgrade again. I have a large number of small mp3s to teach another language. I may need to explore other options outside of the filter but if this worked it would sure be the easy way.
Hide
N Hansen added a comment -

One of my students just gave me a piece of information that might help to solve this problem. She noticed that she could hear the audio on one page on my site, but not another. She is running the latest version of Flash.

The page that is working was last edited in 2006 under Moodle 1.5. The page where the audio isn't working was last edited on March 31 under Moodle 1.6.5. So I looked at the code that was on each page (in editing view), and notice a difference. Here's the code on the page that is working:

<a href="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/a.mp3"> </a></div><param value="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/filter/mediaplugin/mp3player.swf?src=http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/a.mp3" name="movie" /><param value="high" name="quality" /><param value="#333333" name="bgcolor" /> <param value="bgColour=000000&btnColour=ffffff&btnBorderColour=cccccc&iconColour=000000&iconOverColour=00cc00&trackColour=cccccc&handleColour=ffffff&loaderColour=ffffff&waitForPlay=yes" name="flashvars" />

Here's the code on the page that isn't working:

<a href="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/2.6/A.mp3"> </a>

So basically what is going on is that the simple version of code doesn't work with the latest version of Flash. Oddly enough, the code looks the same to me in the actual output on the page. But I may be missing something.

I've manually edited the code on the page that isn't working to add the extra stuff and the players are now playing the sound, so Moodle needs to be made to put in the full code I guess.

Show
N Hansen added a comment - One of my students just gave me a piece of information that might help to solve this problem. She noticed that she could hear the audio on one page on my site, but not another. She is running the latest version of Flash. The page that is working was last edited in 2006 under Moodle 1.5. The page where the audio isn't working was last edited on March 31 under Moodle 1.6.5. So I looked at the code that was on each page (in editing view), and notice a difference. Here's the code on the page that is working: <a href="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/a.mp3"> </a></div><param value="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/filter/mediaplugin/mp3player.swf?src=http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/a.mp3" name="movie" /><param value="high" name="quality" /><param value="#333333" name="bgcolor" /> <param value="bgColour=000000&btnColour=ffffff&btnBorderColour=cccccc&iconColour=000000&iconOverColour=00cc00&trackColour=cccccc&handleColour=ffffff&loaderColour=ffffff&waitForPlay=yes" name="flashvars" /> Here's the code on the page that isn't working: <a href="http://www.glyphdoctors.com/file.php/8/audio/2.6/A.mp3"> </a> So basically what is going on is that the simple version of code doesn't work with the latest version of Flash. Oddly enough, the code looks the same to me in the actual output on the page. But I may be missing something. I've manually edited the code on the page that isn't working to add the extra stuff and the players are now playing the sound, so Moodle needs to be made to put in the full code I guess.
Hide
Jim Eckhardt added a comment -

I tried your fix on my site and was not able to get it to work properly. Although I was not quite sure what to do with the name="move" parameter I changed all the others for the specifics of my site

Here is the location in my site: http://ibwww.org/course/view.php?id=3 its in lesson 6 language

Its works just fine in firefox, both before and after your fix

Your mod changed the behavior of the flash player in ie7 (it doesnt seem to preload the file) but still no sound

Show
Jim Eckhardt added a comment - I tried your fix on my site and was not able to get it to work properly. Although I was not quite sure what to do with the name="move" parameter I changed all the others for the specifics of my site Here is the location in my site: http://ibwww.org/course/view.php?id=3 its in lesson 6 language Its works just fine in firefox, both before and after your fix Your mod changed the behavior of the flash player in ie7 (it doesnt seem to preload the file) but still no sound
Hide
N Hansen added a comment -

It wasn't working for us before the fix in Firefox. It only worked in Firefox with the Flash downgrade. This fix eliminated the need for the Flash downgrade. For other reasons I and my students only use Firefox so I'm afraid I can't help you on IE.

Show
N Hansen added a comment - It wasn't working for us before the fix in Firefox. It only worked in Firefox with the Flash downgrade. This fix eliminated the need for the Flash downgrade. For other reasons I and my students only use Firefox so I'm afraid I can't help you on IE.
Hide
Petr Škoda (skodak) added a comment -

Since 2.0.3 we are using new player, the tests passed in IE6-IE9 with latest 10.2 Flash. Thanks for the report.

Petr

Show
Petr Škoda (skodak) added a comment - Since 2.0.3 we are using new player, the tests passed in IE6-IE9 with latest 10.2 Flash. Thanks for the report. Petr

People

Vote (4)
Watch (5)

Dates

  • Created:
    Updated:
    Resolved: