Moodle Community Sites

The "Moode Sites in Singapore" link to my Moodle site kept disappearing, even after repeated registrations.

Details

  • Type: Bug Bug
  • Status: Resolved Resolved
  • Priority: Minor Minor
  • Resolution: Fixed
  • Component/s: moodle.org
  • Labels:
    None
  • Environment:

Description

As report on http://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=62435 :
(1) My Moodle site (http://NETCoachAsia.com) kept disappearing from the listing, despite repeated registrations using the Notification function in Moodle.
(2) A number of the sites listed there are linking to dead sites.
e.g. ADLER Virtual Learning Environment - the first Arbitration and Dispute Resolution learning portal (Server not found), Childbirth International Student and Member Site and Childbirth International Student and Members Pages (404 Not Found), Elitebizsphere (Page Not Found), Si Ling Secondary School first link (connection has timed out),
(3) One site is even linking to an advertising and non-Moodle site. ETD VLE (pretending to offer Math lessons, but all linking to pages of sponsored links)

The sites mentioned in (2) and (3) were later deleted by Helen Foster. Problem (1) is still there.

NETCoachASia.com is a brand new site, updated daily (almost hourly) so far. There are more than 10 courses, over 20 users, over 80 resources, etc. The site had been installed on PHP 5.0.x using Fantastico. It was migrated to PHP 5.1.x a few days ago.

Issue Links

Activity

Hide
Stuart R Mealor added a comment -

Hi Martin (I notice this seems to be assigned to you?)

It appears that there are quite a few sites listed that are dead links, or non-operational, or just 'demos' (which should not actually be listed).

It's possibly quite a disappointment when visitors click to see other organisations great Moodle sites, to find they are not really there, and only demo's etc.

If you would like someone to manually go through the list I have some time I can assign to one of our people.
We can just go country by country.

Please let me know
Stuart

Show
Stuart R Mealor added a comment - Hi Martin (I notice this seems to be assigned to you?) It appears that there are quite a few sites listed that are dead links, or non-operational, or just 'demos' (which should not actually be listed). It's possibly quite a disappointment when visitors click to see other organisations great Moodle sites, to find they are not really there, and only demo's etc. If you would like someone to manually go through the list I have some time I can assign to one of our people. We can just go country by country. Please let me know Stuart
Hide
J.K. Tan added a comment -

Sorry, Martin. Your name was there by default, and I don't know the other developers and have no idea who's the best person to handle this problem. And I just let it be and submitted the issue.

Stuart, that's a great idea! I second it.

Show
J.K. Tan added a comment - Sorry, Martin. Your name was there by default, and I don't know the other developers and have no idea who's the best person to handle this problem. And I just let it be and submitted the issue. Stuart, that's a great idea! I second it.
Hide
J.K. Tan added a comment -

If users can de-register themselves, this need to clean up the site listing would be lessened.

Show
J.K. Tan added a comment - If users can de-register themselves, this need to clean up the site listing would be lessened.
Hide
J.K. Tan added a comment -

There! The link to my site has just (I think, less than 30mins) disappeared!

Show
J.K. Tan added a comment - There! The link to my site has just (I think, less than 30mins) disappeared!
Hide
Martin Dougiamas added a comment -

I know what the problem was ... two sites somehow had the same random string for the site identification so they kept overwriting each other. I've improved the registration code and this can't happen any more.

Stuart, that's a very generous offer! Contact me via the helpdesk and I'll set you up with access.

Show
Martin Dougiamas added a comment - I know what the problem was ... two sites somehow had the same random string for the site identification so they kept overwriting each other. I've improved the registration code and this can't happen any more. Stuart, that's a very generous offer! Contact me via the helpdesk and I'll set you up with access.
Hide
J.K. Tan added a comment -

Thank you, Martin and Michael (behind the "scenes"), for solving this problem.

Hi, Stuart. Perhaps you can count me in among the people to go country by country to weed out the sites that sites are dead links, or non-operational, or just 'demos' (which should not actually be listed)? Will await your instructions.

Show
J.K. Tan added a comment - Thank you, Martin and Michael (behind the "scenes"), for solving this problem. Hi, Stuart. Perhaps you can count me in among the people to go country by country to weed out the sites that sites are dead links, or non-operational, or just 'demos' (which should not actually be listed)? Will await your instructions.

People

Vote (2)
Watch (2)

Dates

  • Created:
    Updated:
    Resolved: