Uploaded image for project: 'Moodle'
  1. Moodle
  2. MDL-72925

Forum grading separate group filter shows discussion topics in the other groups

XMLWordPrintable

    • MOODLE_310_STABLE, MOODLE_311_STABLE, MOODLE_400_STABLE
    • MOODLE_311_STABLE
    • MDL-72925_master_v2
    • Hide
      1. Login as admin.
        1. Create a course.
        2. Enrol 1 'Non-editing teacher' and 1 'Student' to the course.
        3. Create Group 1 and add the teacher and student.
        4. Create Group 2 and add the student.
        5. Create Group 3 and add the teacher.
        6. Create a forum with following options.
          • Common module settings > Group mode > Separate groups
          • Whole forum grading > Grade > Type > Point
        7. In the forum, choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1'.
        8. Add a new discussion topic 'Discussion 1' to 'Group 1'.
        9. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'.
        10. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 2' for the group.
        11. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 3'.
        12. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 3' for the group.
      2. Login as the student.
        1. Go to the forum.
        2. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 1'.
        3. Click the 'Discussion 1', and reply to the discussion.
        4. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'.
        5. Click the 'Discussion 2', and reply to the discussion.
      3. Login as the teacher.
        1. Go to the forum.
        2. Choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1', and click 'Grade users'.
        3. Choose the student.
        4. Confirm the teacher can see the student's post in 'Discussion 1', but cannot see anything about 'Discussion 2'.
      Show
      Login as admin. Create a course. Enrol 1 'Non-editing teacher' and 1 'Student' to the course. Create Group 1 and add the teacher and student. Create Group 2 and add the student. Create Group 3 and add the teacher. Create a forum with following options. Common module settings > Group mode > Separate groups Whole forum grading > Grade > Type > Point In the forum, choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1'. Add a new discussion topic 'Discussion 1' to 'Group 1'. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 2' for the group. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 3'. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 3' for the group. Login as the student. Go to the forum. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 1'. Click the 'Discussion 1', and reply to the discussion. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'. Click the 'Discussion 2', and reply to the discussion. Login as the teacher. Go to the forum. Choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1', and click 'Grade users'. Choose the student. Confirm the teacher can see the student's post in 'Discussion 1', but cannot see anything about 'Discussion 2'.

      In the MDL-70176, we fixed the issue for 'separate group filter' to show other group students.
      This is an issue for 'separate group filter' to show a discussion topic for the other group.

      Steps to replicate:

      1. Login as admin.
        1. Create a course.
        2. Enrol 1 'Non-editing teacher' and 1 'Student' to the course.
        3. Create Group 1 and add the teacher and student.
        4. Create Group 2 and add the student.
        5. Create Group 3 and add the teacher.
        6. Create a forum with following options.
          • Common module settings > Group mode > Separate groups
          • Whole forum grading > Grade > Type > Point
        7. In the forum, choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1'.
        8. Add a new discussion topic 'Discussion 1' to 'Group 1'.
        9. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'.
        10. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 2' for the group.
        11. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 3'.
        12. Add a new discussion 'Discussion 3' for the group.
      2. Login as the student.
        1. Go to the forum.
        2. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 1'.
        3. Click the 'Discussion 1', and reply to the discussion.
        4. Choose 'Separate group' to 'Group 2'.
        5. Click the 'Discussion 2', and reply to the discussion.
      3. Login as the teacher.
        1. Go to the forum.
        2. Choose 'Separate groups' to 'Group 1', and click 'Grade users'.
        3. Choose the student.
        4. Teacher can see 'Discussion 1' and the student's post.
        5. Teacher can also see the 'Discussion 2' but only title. 'Discussion 2' is for 'Group 2'. The 'Separate groups' filter doesn't work properly.

            tomotsuyuki Tomo Tsuyuki
            tomotsuyuki Tomo Tsuyuki
            cameron1729 cameron1729
            Jun Pataleta Jun Pataleta
            Gladys Basiana Gladys Basiana
            Votes:
            1 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            6 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:

                Estimated:
                Original Estimate - 0 minutes
                0m
                Remaining:
                Remaining Estimate - 0 minutes
                0m
                Logged:
                Time Spent - 2 hours, 30 minutes
                2h 30m

                  Error rendering 'clockify-timesheets-time-tracking-reports:timer-sidebar'. Please contact your Jira administrators.